Sections and prompts from the model cards paper, v2. (Mitchell et al. (2019)).
Jump to section:
Basic information about the model.
Review section 4.1 of the model cards paper.
Use cases that were envisioned during development.
Review section 4.2 of the model cards paper.
Factors could include demographic or phenotypic groups, environmental conditions, technical attributes, or others listed in Section 4.3.
Review section 4.3 of the model cards paper.
The appropriate metrics to feature in a model card depend on the type of model that is being tested. For example, classification systems in which the primary output is a class label differ significantly from systems whose primary output is a score. In all cases, the reported metrics should be determined based on the model’s structure and intended use.
Review section 4.4 of the model cards paper.
All referenced datasets would ideally point to any set of documents that provide visibility into the source and composition of the dataset. Evaluation datasets should include datasets that are publicly available for third-party use. These could be existing datasets or new ones provided alongside the model card analyses to enable further benchmarking.
Review section 4.5 of the model cards paper.
Review section 4.6 of the model cards paper.
Quantitative analyses should be disaggregated, that is, broken down by the chosen factors. Quantitative analyses should provide the results of evaluating the model according to the chosen metrics, providing confidence interval values when possible.
Review section 4.7 of the model cards paper.
This section is intended to demonstrate the ethical considerations that went into model development, surfacing ethical challenges and solutions to stakeholders. Ethical analysis does not always lead to precise solutions, but the process of ethical contemplation is worthwhile to inform on responsible practices and next steps in future work.
Review section 4.8 of the model cards paper.
This section should list additional concerns that were not covered in the previous sections.
Review section 4.9 of the model cards paper.